More than 370 scouts have successfully attained the rank of Eagle over the years in Troop 12. These are the Eagle Scouts who have attained that rank since June 2007.
| Scout Name | Date Eagle was Completed | Court of Honor |
| Philip Spinelli | 11/30/06 | Jun-07 |
| Andrew Giustina | 3/22/07 | Jun-07 |
| Alan Gaskin | 4/12/07 | Jun-07 |
| Derek Cousins | 4/19/07 | Jun-07 |
| Zack Green | 4/26/07 | Jun-07 |
| Andrew Bennett-Jackson | 5/3/07 | Jun-07 |
| James Cantine | 11/8/07 | Feb-08 |
| Jake Sandor | 3/6/08 | Jun-08 |
| Kenneth Cousins | 4/17/08 | Jun-08 |
| Everett Glenn | 4/28/08 | Jun-08 |
| Gerald Evans | 11/6/08 | Feb-09 |
| Chase Starks | 4/8/09 | Jun-09 |
| William Deehan | 4/16/09 | Jun-09 |
| Ryan Walpole | 4/16/09 | Jun-09 |
| David Dandridge | 10/28/09 | Feb-10 |
| Gregory Silverstein | 11/5/09 | Feb-10 |
| Benjamin Hadley | 11/19/09 | Feb-10 |
| Joseph Giustina | 10/29/09 | Jun-10 |
| Drew Schmetterling | 3/25/10 | Jun-10 |
| Christopher Cusenza | 3/25/10 | Jun-10 |
| Kristoffel VanWinden | 3/25/10 | Jun-10 |
| Eric Frazzano | 11/11/10 | Feb-11 |
| Thomas Smith | 11/18/10 | Feb-11 |
| Dashiel McLaughlin | 11/22/10 | Jun-11 |
| Joel Elder | 4/18/11 | Jun-11 |
| Leo Foglizzo | 10/12/11 | Feb-12 |
| Benjamin Spinelli | 4/18/12 | Jun-12 |
| Jake Thomas | 6/26/12 | Feb-13 |
| Tate Bowers | 9/13/12 | Jun-13 |
| Alexander Hadley | 10/18/12 | Feb-13 |
| Stephen Shaheen | 11/29/12 | Feb-13 |
| Gabriel Umar | 11/29/12 | Jun-13 |
| Austin Williams | 3/18/13 | Jun-13 |
| James Creaser | 11/6/13 | Feb-14 |
| Ian Leong | 12/2/13 | Feb-14 |
| Thomas Pool | 12/2/13 | Feb-14 |
| Moses Lewis | 4/9/14 | Jun-14 |
| Carter Jackson | 6/2/14 | Jun-15 |
| Ben Beinish | 7/20/15 | Feb-16 |
| CJ Kaloudis | 8/31/15 | Feb-16 |
| Max Koep | 8/31/15 | Feb-16 |
| Jack DeSantis | 10/19/15 | Feb-16 |
| Caleb DeSmith | 11/9/15 | Feb-16 |
| Sam Joslyn | 11/3/16 | Feb-17 |
| Jack Brandon | 11/28/16 | Feb-17 |
| Peter Brown | 4/3/17 | Jun-17 |
| Jake Skorzewski | 4/11/17 | Jun-17 |
| Arjun Nischol | 7/2/17 | Feb-18 |
| Justin Leong | 10/18/17 | Feb-18 |
| GianLuca Roses | 12/19/17 | Feb-18 |
| Marcos Parada | 10/18/18 | Feb-19 |
| Thomas DeSantis | 3/18/19 | Jun-19 |
| Michael DeSantis | 3/18/19 | Jun-19 |
| Eron Eden | 4/8/19 | Jun-19 |
| Armaan Nischol | 4/29/19 | Jun-19 |
| Sam Lagasse | 2/9/21 | Jun-21 |
| Curtis DeSmith | 3/4/21 | Jun-21 |
| Alex Parada | 9/29/21 | Jun-22 |
| Max Ferrante | 10/26/21 | Jun-22 |
| Denzel Loblack | 2/21/22 | Jun-22 |
| Lucas Hususan | 7/26/23 | Jun-24 |
| Elia Eden | 8/11/23 | Jun-24 |
| Aiden Kwiatkowski | 9/21/23 | Feb-24 |
| Liam Varnelis | 9/26/23 | Feb-24 |
| Mikey Hadley | 9/27/23 | Feb-24 |